Spread across thousands of islands bustling with beautiful flora and fauna, Indonesia is the world's largest island country. Over the centuries, its people have welcomed several cultures they came across through trade and commerce. As a result, we now have a melting pot of cultures in Indonesia to study and appreciate.
Though officially a secular nation, Indonesia is home to the largest Muslim population in the world, with about 87 percent of Indonesians following Islam. Other religions that coexist peacefully include Christianity, Hinduism and Buddhism.
The people of Indonesia are traditional and prefer to follow a more conservative approach to life. Indonesian culture influences age ratings for digital music, film and television in myriad ways.
Sexual Material in Music
Sex and sexuality are topics that Indonesians do not openly discuss. In fact, transgressions can carry heavy consequences. Music that contains sexual lyrics is regulated by the broadcasting authority. In early 2019, the West Java provincial broadcast commission listed 85 songs labelled 'adult' which could only be aired between 10 p.m. and 3 a.m. Popular English language songs, including Ed Sheeran's "Shape of You," Bruno Mars' "That's What I Like," and Ariana Grande's "Love Me Harder," were considered vulgar and negative .
Decency and Decorum
Indonesians prefer to dress modestly in public. The government has in recent years grown more conservative with regards to acceptable clothing choices, particularly for women. It came as less of a surprise when an advertisement for the South Korean female pop group Blackpink was banned because its members dressed in miniskirts. The Indonesian Broadcasting Commission ordered nearly a dozen domestic TV stations to pull the commercial, citing indecency .
Indonesia's decency filter is applicable to cartoons and works of animation as well. In 2017, the Indonesian Broadcasting Commission (IBC) issued a warning letter about a kissing scene in the cartoon series "Shaun The Sheep." The authority pointed out that the show violated Article 14 on child protection and Article 16 on the limitation of sexual content in the Broadcasting Code of Conduct and Broadcasting Standards. "SpongeBob SquarePants" and "Doraemon" also drew attention from the IBC as each had a female character sporting swimwear in one or more episodes. The images of these characters in swimwear were subsequently blurred out.
Religious Matters:
As Islam is the predominant religion practiced in Indonesia, authorities protect religious sentiments and seek to minimize or eliminate potentially upsetting material. One example is the Hollywood movie "Noah" starring Russell Crowe. The 2014 film was banned by the Indonesian Film Censorship Board, stating that the story contradicted Quran teachings and may mislead people .
The current trend in Indonesia continues toward a conservative approach. Government authorities closely monitor the Media and Entertainment industry to ensure the sensibilities of the Indonesian people are not offended.
Cultural Landscape: Thailand
Thailand is a melting pot of different people and cultures. At present, over 52% of the population resides in cities. Primarily a Buddhist country, about 94.6% of its citizens follow the Theravada tradition and the remaining 4.3% and 1.1% observe Islam and Christianity respectively .
While Thailand is more open and welcoming than other Asian countries, it too, has points of cultural sensitivity. Presented below are a few examples of its conservative side.
Respect for Buddhism
Religious respect is deeply rooted in Thai culture. Buddhism and its belief symbols are revered, and any gesture of disrespect is unacceptable by person or in media. In 2015, the Thai Culture Ministry banned horror movie "Arbat" citing contempt for Buddhism. The movie depicted Thai monks engaging in misconduct including drinking, consuming drugs and having improper relations with women. Moreover, the Thailand Film Censorship Board stated that some scenes disrespected Buddha.
This is not an isolated incident. Over the years, the Board banned several films it deemed disparaging to Buddhism and Buddhists.
Political Sensitivity
Thailand is quite politically sensitive and films with political content undergo cautious scrutiny in the country. Consider the 2012 film "Shakespeare Must Die." This adaptation of Shakespeare's play Macbeth was banned by the country's culture minister citing it would "cause divisions between Thai people" due to its underlying references criticizing Thai politics and monarchy through characters such as a dictator named Dear Leader. In "Symmetry of Splendour," the independent filmmaker did not release this film in Thailand in fear of government reprisals due to its references to the 1965 military crackdown, albeit it received critically acclaimed reviews around the world.
Moral Sensitivity
The film "Syndromes and a Century" also received global critical acclaim. However, the director, Apichatpong Weerasethakul pulled the release rather than comply with the Thailand Film Censorship Board's demand that four scenes be cut. Those contentious scenes depicted characters kissing and using alcohol and Buddhist monks playing the guitar and with a remote-control toy.
LGBTQ Representation
The 2010 film about a transgender father, "Insects in the Backyard," was banned for "violating the moral values of society." This inspired the movie maker, Tanwarin Sukkhapisit to join politics and become the first transgender parliament member in the country. A seven-year-long legal battle for the movie's release resulted in screening approval for audiences aged 20 and above after a three-second nudity scene was cut. Tanwarin Sukkhapisit also sought an amendment to the Film and Video Act to improve freedom of expression and better gender equality.
Thailand is a place of majestic natural beauty with a vital and varied culture. While change is potent and inevitable, Thai citizens strive to maintain traditions and preserve their heritage as they enter each new era.
